May 25, 2017 Last Updated 3:32 PM, May 24, 2017
Published in Editorial
Read 203 times
Rate this item
(0 votes)
Tagged under

A grain of salt

Antihero is a turn-based strategy game, set in the Victorian era, that involves burgling houses, forming gangs, and forcing street urchins to do your bidding. Or, at least it will be; I played the Early Access version, and the full version is expected to release in mid-June. A story-based campaign is supposed to accompany the release, which would definitely add depth to the experience, but one can’t evaluate hypothetical content, so this review focuses on what is actually present so far. That said, Antihero has potential, so take any criticism with a grain of salt.

Antihero’s setting is full of character.

The dark Victorian setting is a great choice for the sneakery and skullduggery of this title. The characters speak in caricatured English accents, and the artwork serves well the game’s dark, cartoony humor. Among the more interesting characters is the gang leader, who is essentially Daniel Day-Lewis (similar voice and all) from Gangs of New York. Although he technically seems to be on the wrong continent, it’s a fun choice on the part of the developer. The truant officer is another great addition, since the creepy, pale, bald man stuffs urchins into his prison-like horse cart with an enthusiasm that can only be described as “amusing.”

You can also choose from a wide selection of master thieves to lead your guild, but as of yet this is only a cosmetic choice. We can only hope that, in the final release, the master thieves are differentiated from one another, each uniquely affecting gameplay in some way.

The victory conditions provide for a wide variety of strategies.

There are a few different map choices, each of which comes with its own way to get victory points. In most cases, you need five victory points to win, and these can be earned by blackmailing churches [EN: Nice.], buying bribes, or assassinating targets. With a tech tree that focuses on three different areas, the variety of victory point-acquisition methods allows for a few different strategies to keep matches interesting.

The maps add to this: For instance, if you are at the harbor, you can infiltrate cargo ships for victory points. In another map, you can steal invitations to masquerade parties in order to sneak into a manor and steal valuable heirlooms. And, if you play on the palace map, you can take control of guard towers and leave the palace vulnerable to burglary – a required condition for victory.

With two types of resources, one generally used for upgrades and the other used for hiring lackeys, a few options are available to grow your thieves’ guild and attain your nefarious goals. Infiltrating and upgrading buildings with urchins allows for different ways to modify your economy and abilities in a manner that satisfyingly scratches the itch for those of us that love upgrades.

However, the small tech trees get a little boring after a few games. For example, thugs are not incredibly useful, yet they have three upgrades devoted to them, two of which just add another health point. The same goes with the variety of buildings. There are some interesting strategies – fully upgrading the orphanage allows your urchins to evict enemies from their buildings, which is OP in a satisfying way – but again, after a couple of playthroughs, you are left fruitlessly searching for more options in this vein.

Everything, from characters, to victory points, to map variety, leaves you with the same feeling: Antihero seems anticlimactic and unfinished. Fortunately, in this case, that’s because it is.

Antihero leaves you wanting.

The core gameplay that has been released for Early Access is promising and relatively bug-free – I only had trouble with the map in the beginning because I reflexively wanted to push the mouse to the edge of the screen to move around but found I needed to click and drag, which was vexing when dialogue boxes kept popping up outside the visible area. Regardless of its solid design, the title as it is now leaves you wishing there were more.

The developers note that the AI is currently pretty dumb and, indeed, it’s easy to trounce an AI opponent, once you get the hang of the mechanics. Left without a satisfying challenge, you must explore the experimental multiplayer options. Instant multiplayer is still in development, and you need a friend ready to play with you because there is no matchmaking yet. “Hot seat” is good if you have a friend nearby – it plays like a two person board game.

There’s also a multiplayer mode where you take your turn, and then it e-mails your opponent to prompt them to take their turn. This is a very old way of doing games that, in a modern context, can seem like an awful idea at first (like playing chess through the mail), but it can actually work out pretty well. You can alt-tab and go do other things, then the program will make a sound and flash in your toolbar when your opponent has finished. Plus, it is admittedly very satisfying to finally win against an actual human opponent after a lengthy back-and-forth in this mode.

The Verdict

Antihero is fairly well balanced and the mechanics are solid, but there just isn’t enough of it yet to make it stand out. It definitely has potential to entertain with its funny-yet-dark art and play styles, but so far it lacks any sort of story or variety. While I have high hopes for this title, we will just have to wait and see if it lives up to its potential.

Image Gallery

View the embedded image gallery online at:
Nicholas Barkdull

Nic is a freelance writer, doctoral student, and devout PC gamer. He says he's not a hipster but still insists that the best games are either decades old or made by one guy in a basement. This includes things like Undertale or any Final Fantasy that was released on Super Nintendo. He is also an RTS fanatic.

Related items

  • Idle Evolution Review

    Idle Evolution takes a novel look at how one can develop an idle clickers, and implements the concept exceptionally well. This release also sets the stage for future idle titles, and sets the bar rather high; Idle Evolution arguably heralds the dawn of a new era for this genre.

  • Planescape: Torment: Enhanced Edition Review

    Somewhere between science-fiction and fantasy, portals, magic, and warriors exist in a chaotic junction between existences. Worlds collide, and you're left to forge your own path, and discover more than you had ever realized. Planescape: Torment: Enhanced Edition is a gem of a game, which brings a long-lost treasure home, rested, refreshed, renewed, and ready for more adventure.

  • A Rose in The Twilight Review

    A Rose in The Twilight is a visually stunning yet straightforward puzzle-platformer with a macabre atmosphere and an adorable main character. The storyline and the dialogue tend to fall short, but with unique game mechanics and beautiful design, lovers of the genre can enjoy the delightful characters while testing their mettle on the challenging puzzles of this title.

  • Afghanistan '11 Review

    The attention to detail in the game mechanics, the developers’ efforts to maintain relevance and historical accuracy, and the rewards of mastering its intricacies set Afghanistan '11 apart as an exceptional title. However, an unusually steep learning curve, which might be hard to accept for someone who wants to casually try a turn-based strategy game, keep this release from broader appeal.

  • Europa Universalis IV: Mandate of Heaven Review

    With Mandate of Heaven, Paradox Interactive has proven once more that they consistently deliver expansions which incorporate suggestions from players and satisfy their gamership's desire for new, immersive content -- once a newcomer overcomes the steep learning curve. Additionally, the downloadable content offers improved features for the game interface and new concepts in gameplay, contributing to a deep, involving, and rewarding experience.

  • Bomb Squad Academy Review

    Bomb Squad Academy is more fun than it is challenging. Negative feedback to the player, other than the bomb blowing up (of course), is thin, but this results in an approachable, replayable atmosphere. This is a fantastic puzzler with complex and unique mechanics that are presented to the player in an easily digestible way.

  • Lifeline – Great for the brain, necessary for the soul.

    Be mindful that if you pick this title up, which I think you should, you’ll be doing all the legwork in your brain while still keeping your heart rate down. Though simple and straightforward, and thoroughly enjoyable, this style of gameplay is not for everyone. That said, take some time away from the crazy stuff and chill out with Lifeline. Hats off to the developer for putting together a great story in an elegant, minimal package that still brings it home.

  • Learn Japanese To Survive! Katakana War Review

    One of the best virtual introductions to a new language I have ever seen. Thanks to Learn Japanese To Survive!Katakana War, one could be well on their way to learning the Japanese language while immersing themselves in a genuinely fun game.

Latest Shows

OPN DevLounge Mo…

Episode Five, Season One! OPN's DevLounge Monthly is a lively conversation between game developers on Twitch, on the hottest PC games to be released this upcoming month. Watch it o...

NieR: Automata -…

With AAA Anonymous, we discuss our latest AAA game addiction, until the next one replaces it. This episode covers SQUARE Enix's PC release of NieR Automata.

Out Soon

PC Gaming Incoming

Shootout on Cash…

Shootout in Cash Island it's an absurd action platformer and also a side story to HOT GUNS game. Bob...

Final Fantasy XI…

Dive into the next chapter of the critically acclaimed game FINAL FANTASY XIV Online with its epic n...

Danganronpa Anot…

Komaru Naegi has been imprisoned inside a mysterious apartment for over a year. Her rescue is derail...

Micro Machines W…

The legend is back! Micro Machines World Series combines the thrilling madness of racing micro vehic...

Old Man's Journe…

In the brief time it takes to complete it, Old Man’s Journey plays out the calm yet deliberate journey of an aging man, set to right the wrongs of his youth once upon a time he cho...

Empathy: Path of…

Between the graphics and exploring this abandoned world and piecing together what happened, Empathy: Path of Whispers is incredible and highly recommend, even if you might not usua...

OVIVO Review

Ovivo is a beautiful piece that melds art, exploration, and mystery in a unique platform–adventure title. The levels are engaging, the gameplay intuitive. Unfortunately, the lack o...

The Infectious M…

The Infectious Madness of Doctor Dekker delivers a fresh, memorable, and intricately woven tale of psychological horror. The developer's experience in crafting murder mysteries sho...