Oct 17, 2017 Last Updated 12:52 PM, Oct 17, 2017

OPNOOBS site guilty of Review Manipulation and betray their writers

Published in Editorial
Read 1183 times
Rate this item
(0 votes)
Tagged under
NOTICE: in light of the messages we received from the PC gaming community that reacted to  our interactions with Youtuber Sidalpha, we are reinstating all unpublished reviews. This project is underway and due to our limited resources, is scheduled to complete by the end of 2017.

Editor's note: SidAlpha, the grammatically correct version of your YouTube title should read: "OPNOOBS site guilty of Review Manipulation and betraying their writers." You're welcome =)

I woke up this morning with some hundreds of text messages, emails, and tweets about OPNOOBS, the biased website that changes review scores to please industry professionals.

At the source of the attack, is YouTuber SidAlpha and his video OPNOOBS site guilty of Review Manipulation and betray their writers.

Watch it, enjoy the dramatic spins, and allow me to defend our site, and all the talented writers behind it.

I’ll begin by pointing out a few things SidAlpha is correct about.

“Game critics have a tough road in this industry (…). The ability to earn a living is virtually impossible”

SidAlpha, you are correct! I’m not making money; I’m losing it! Don’t believe me? Call my wife.

The Overpowered Noobs have been operating since September 2014 at a deficit. We have never made a cent, much even less a dollar off of a review, and we invest our personal time and incomes daily, with no prospects of generating profits whatsoever.


Because we are a community of passionate PC gamers, who write in support of the independent scene – we believe they keep the industry creative and AAA studios from falling into recipes and clichés the way cinema has overtime. We write to provide much needed coverage, good or bad, to talented developers who simply aren’t getting enough from the mainstream press, often for the reason that they don’t carry enough weight in the gaming scene to bring anything of significant value to bigger sites.

For the record, we are not ones to criticize mainstream press. In fact, I personally admire their production output and the quality of the writing. They are a source of inspiration to us and we hope to continue improving our content, so that one day, we might be as respected as they are among the industry. Having said this, we do feel that they could provide much more coverage for the little fishes in the sea, especially those talented enough to deserve it.

Now let’s move on to Sid’s distorted attack.

What happens when the publications you work for not only make significant changes to both your review and score, but then eliminates all of your work by deleting it from the site, firing you and a host of other writers, all following in the coattails of being admitted as a confirmed Metacritic site?

We started like so many other entrepreneurial teams on earth.

From the dirt, and with nothing other than an uphill battle ahead of us. I recall the long nights, the teams breaking down, the personal time away from family when my newborn was ready for his dad. But I wasn’t. At least not half as much as I wanted to. Personally, I had and I still must build something, and both my colleagues and I knew it would take a tremendous amount of work and commitment to make it happen.

Early on and all the way until mid-2016, the writing on OPNOOBS was less than stellar.

We had to start somewhere, right? Getting the ball rolling was the priority at the time, though, and meeting gamers from all walks of life, so as to create a talent community that would bring a breath of fresh air and a real support base to a booming indie scene. Simply click on this link of upcoming games this week, and also take a look at the sheer amount of games waiting for some attention from press… Sadly, there is so little coverage to support them!

We always felt that was a shame, and I hope you, the independent thinker, will agree.

You fired people, you capitalistic you!?

They were all, for the record, volunteers.

Not employees, but volunteers. Hence the inflammatory word in your video, “fired,” is grossly incorrect. You influence people, SidAlpha, and hats off to you for being successful. But please check your facts, if you want to be respected in the long run.

And yes! I hate to say it, but there is such a thing as good writing, vs. poor writing.

Now let me walk you through this butchery called business standards.

In 2015, we applied to Metacritic. To no avail. We did not get the accreditation and, frankly, rightfully so. The quality in the writing just wasn’t there.

This meant that at the turn of 2016, we decided to make some real tough decisions in the writing department, letting go of people we had come to know as friends. At the time, we dismissed far more writers than we did at the turn of 2017.

Toward the end of the year, we applied again. Metacritic considered us once more, and this time, recognized how much we had evolved. They accredited OPNOOBS, and yes, it did bring tears to my eyes. So much work; so much dedication. The naysayers were proven wrong, and we were at last rewarded for persevering.

Now Tony Villareal was still around, among a few others whom, albeit being good people (Tony obviously excluded), we felt did not have the skill level to carry us forward in this new era. Most accepted the fact that we had to bid farewell, but he didn’t and he certainly did a good job at taking his frustration into a platform where he might be heard. Sorry, Tony. I still wish you well.

Happy Columbus Day

Not to get too philosophical on you all, but yeah… The immigrant in me saw the accreditation and appreciated the big win it symbolized as a true expression of American meritocracy. I’m glad there are people like the one I won't name, running parts of a company as influential as Metacritic. People like him make the world go round: they recognize hard work and a job done right, regardless of who you are and who your father is. And I hope our small and humble success be a source of inspiration to others gamers trying to get something up and running. You should. Because if you’ve got the resilience and stamina for it, this country will acknowledge and reward you for it. That’s what makes it so great.

You changed the review score!?

Most of the time it’s to bring it down. No more 9’s and 10’s at every turn. PLEASE.

Yes, but before publishing it! And we do this all the time – before publishing it! That’s because we have a strict grading scale which, by the way, is much tougher than other game sites.

It is our belief that games are overhyped, and 9’s and 10’s are far too numerous! The 2017 grading scale saw some further adjustments in that direction.

Now if a writer doesn’t understand our grading, we look at what he’s saying. Then we adjust his score based on how his writing reads. We communicate that to them, and they’re for the most part (Tony obviously excluded), appreciative of it.

Journalist integrity? Screenshots attached. ‘Nuff said.

At the end of the day, I’ll let you be the judge of who we are and what we stand for. I do hope you’ll take a step back before following the herd that points a finger. I commented on YouTube, but the crowd didn't believe it was the President. That's how disconnected the press is from the community. Not us. So if you have any comments or concerns, you can always email me at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.. Always happy to chat.

LAST BUT NOT LEAST: I invite Sid Alpha to debate me on Twitch. I won’t run away from OPNOOBS. Our team deserves far better from me than that. So, Sid Alpha, if you’re man enough. Come face me!

SidAlpha vs. OPNOOBS Part 2! - Annexed on 10/10/2017

SidAlpha's Response

FROM FRED TO SIDALPHA: I apologize for throwing that jab at you. In my own defense, it was on a humorous tone... I'm pretty sure you are man enough... considering how tough and direct your channel is!

For the record, I'm not inviting you on Twitch to corner you. I'm inviting you to have a polite and open discussion about what we did at the turn of 2015 and 2016, for you perhaps to better understand our motivations, and for me to better understand yours and how we might have handled our growth better.

Honestly - parts of your arguments I get; but I think you're tough on us and then, on others, I just disagree and I would like to explain why.
I'm not an aggressive guy and if you do accept, I promise you to conduct myself in the most professional of manners, in a positive environment, and there won't be anything on the stream that would make you feel either unwelcomed or insulted. You have my word.

Would you please consider it? I think it would help both parties.

You've also given me quite some food for thoughts...

And I'm going to recognize a shortcoming and try to rectify our mistake. I heard you loud and clear on one specific point, and also thanks to people like Logan and Chiara, who have contacted me directly. They too helped me realize that something we did was messed up.

I hope you understand wanting to raise the writing level on the site. Still... No matter the quality behind the writing, pulling down the reviews from opnoobs, that indeed, people had worked on, was a messed up thing to do. We should have been more respectful of the time they had invested and their commitment... So here's what we're going to do.

We will restore the content pulled down, under a new section of the site, which we will label "community reviews." This way we still separate it from what our editorial board considers to meet today's standards on the site, but not at the cost of giving the deserved exposure to our former writers.

I hope that will show that I'm not that full of myself, and that I can recognize when I make mistakes. I'm only human and like many others, I've made a ton of them in the past couple years. I learn everyday.

I also and still hope you will accept my invitation to talk on Twitch, and hopefully you'll find that I'm not so arrogant and bully-like.

If not, I wish you the best.

Fred Brizzi

Fred is OpNoobs' loyal and undeserving Presidente. He started gaming with Alex Kidd on the Sega Master System back in 1986 and was brought by ID Software to the PC when DOOM hit the shelves in 1993. He lives in Washington, D.C., with his wife and child, plays international politics by day, and games by night. His dream? To leave the elephants and the donkeys at the zoo, and eat, pray, love PC gaming 101% of the time. In fact, when he's not working for OpNoobs, he's apologizing to his wife for OpNoobs.

Related items

  • Aftercharge Interview with Chainsawesome Games

    The studio itself was established in 2012 by three people — two programmers and one artist — who had gained experience working in different studios before, but mostly with one studio (that is) in Quebec City, which is called Frima Studio. They decided to try it on their own and began working on a project which was later canceled because it had been too ambitious. Their first successful project was BeatBlasters III which is a game they released on PC. It’s a rhythm game with platformer and puzzle elements — a unique take on those genres. It didn’t perform very well, like most first games of a studio. They didn't invest much in marketing.

  • Devil Dagger’s Die-Hard Devotees

    Devil Daggers is created by Matt “m4ttbush” Bush, under the company Sorath. I’m greeted with screenshots that depict a hand engulfed in embers, firing countless daggers from its fingertips at hordes of lovecraftian enemies. The room is dark: there are no walls or ceilings, only a dark void. The faint illumination from the main character reveals ancient stone floors beneath. The entire color scheme seems to stick with three, maybe four colors at once — all dusty reds or luminescent yellows. They are hugging vertices that I have not seen since Quake, and they look brilliant combined.

  • Chronicles of Nyanya Interview

    Who doesn’t love cats? (Rhetorical question, folks — I’m awfully allergic to the diminutive felines, myself.) But still, even in ancient Egyptian and Asian cultures, cats have always seemed to be… around. Enter one of the last survivors of the Greenlight program: Chronicles of NyaNya, a cRPG ]by  Ilona Myszkowska, Polish comic artist and creator of the very popular chatolandia.pl. [EN: I looked it up, and no, the “c” does not stand for “cat”]

  • tinyBuild sponsors cash prizes for indie devs

    tinyBuild today announced their sponsoring in hard cash prizes of indie games at a game development event in Minsk, Belarus. The event is called DevGAMM and has the region's biggest game awards show.

  • The Town of Light from a Mind of Darkness

    I interviewed Luca Dalcò from the small Italian indie studio LKA located in the picturesque landscape of Chianti, Italy. Luca Dalcò recently released The Town of Light (ToL). Particular about this title is its treatment of the subject of mental health. While it is an important issue here as well as across the big pond, it is a topic that, if it doesn’t receive a sexy packaging like the Joker in the Batman franchise, seldom is subject matter for video games, because of the stigma and taboo it still carries.

  • Mantis Burn Racing: 'Battle Cars' DLC Interview

    The OPN interview showcasing the release of VooFoo Studios' 'Battle cars' DLC for the fast-paced, competitive, top-down racer, 'Mantis Burn Racing.' A conversation with Creative Director Shaun Read and Marketing and PR Manager Sean Walsh. Interviewed by our Editor-in-Chief, Rey Urias, and our Director of Business Development, Enzo Scavone.

  • We Need To Go Deeper Early Access Interview

    The OPN interview with Deli Interactive. We Need to Go Deeper is a 2-4-player cooperative submarine roguelike set in a Verne-inspired undersea universe. In the game, you and your crew must embark on many voyages into a mysterious undersea trench known as The Living Infinite.

  • Utomik Interview

    The OPN interview with Frank Meijer. Utomik is the no-nonsense unlimited play gaming subscription that offers a growing library of games from over 20 leading publishers. Gamers can effortlessly discover and play games in a single click, thanks to Utomik’s innovative ‘download while you play technology’. You get the real game instantly, not a streamed surrogate.

Latest Indie Reviews

The Indie Scene, Under Review.

Latest on Twitch

Watch it live on twitch.tv/opnoobsonline.

Latest Shows

Children of the …

The OPN interview with Jason Kim, Cardboard Utopia. Children of Zodiarcs is a story-driven, tactical RPG set in the fantasy realm of Lumus; a world divided by affluence and poverty...

Crumple Intervie…

The OPN Dev Talk with Gabriel Gutierrez from Nascent Games, on their title newly release title "Crumple." A great conversation about what it takes to get a studio on the run, and o...

Out Soon

PC Gaming Incoming

Throne of Lies R…

Throne of Lies is yet another addition to the very specific social deduction genre, requiring time and patience to get the best experience.  For those who don’t mind doing a little...

Raiders of the B…

Raiders of the Broken Planet just isn’t there yet. While an alpha build of the title showed promise, the title has much development ground to cover yet. Raiders of the Broken Plane...

Echo Review

Echo proves that innovation can truly be limitless as long as there are people willing to push boundaries and explore new ideas. With a stunningly flawless trifecta of gameplay, st...

Asura Vengeance …

While there are some pitfalls, the Asura: Vengeance expansion packs enough content to satisfy returning players and entice new ones. New game mode adds an addictive alternative to ...